Engagment, growth, and results. Just three reasons Topps Tiles renews with Thrive
Find out more
October 21, 2025
|
6 mins to read
|
Technology

Rethinking the digital workplace: Why EXPs fell short and what’s next 

Why digital workplaces failed to live up to their promise — and how a new, human-centred approach can finally make them work.
Robyn Till
Marketing

For years, the industry has promised a seamless, human-centred “digital workplace.” If we could just build the right intranet or employee experience platform (EXP), we’d unlock connection, productivity, and engagement.

It didn’t happen.

Despite billions spent, most digital workplaces are still unintuitive and underused. They’re built around systems rather than people, and they serve hierarchy rather than experience.

So what really went wrong, and how can we do better? 

The engagement illusion

Research from Gartner shows that nearly 60% of employees struggle to find the information they need to do their job efficiently, even in companies that have invested heavily in digital workplace tech. 

And while intranet usage has technically increased post-pandemic, less than half of workers say those tools make them feel more connected or productive. 

In short, we’ve basically spent millions digitising chaos.

Back in 2019, Employee Experience Platforms were billed as the future of work. But as Bertrand Duperrin points out, the idea “seems to have evaporated.” The tools promised connection, but rarely delivered it.

Instead of reshaping how people work, they layered new tech over legacy systems. They centralised content, but ignored context.

“We digitised chaos and called it transformation.”

Forrester’s 2025 EX Management Platforms report found that only those who combined insight with genuine design thinking made a measurable difference. Most platforms didn’t fail because they were bad products; they failed because they were built for the organisation, not for employees.

So when you drill it down, EXPs just became corporate intranets, acting as a digital filing cabinet with prettier fonts and layouts. But most intranets or “EXPs” collapse under the same pressures: poor search, clunky UX, no (or poor) integrations, and weak governance. 

The result being: 

  • Employers still resorting to email or chat for answers 
  • Policies going out of date faster than they're updated 
  • Single sources of truth splintering into silos 
  • Engagement dashboards looking healthy, while nobody is actually using the system as intended 

The seven pain points every digital workplace suffers from 

According to Digital Workplace Group, most organisations share the same frustrations. These are the symptoms of a broken digital front door:

1. Notification overload

Between Teams, Slack, HR alerts, and inbox pings, employees live in a state of constant interruption. Each context switch fractures attention and focus.

2. Information overload

Gartner found that nearly 60% of employees struggle to find what they need to do their job efficiently (Gartner 2025 HR Trends). The average worker spends nearly two hours a day searching for information that should be seconds away.

3. Onboarding friction

Instead of clarity, new joiners face a mess of systems, links, and logins. The first impression of your company culture is confusion.

4. Cluttered design

Without role-based personalisation, interfaces become junk drawers. No signal, just noise.

5. Workflow disconnect

When the platform doesn’t reflect what employees actually do each day — approvals, priorities, collaboration — it becomes irrelevant.

6. Tech distrust

If content is inconsistent or outdated, employees stop relying on the system entirely. They make their own.

7. Content entropy

Without governance, pages pile up, duplicates appear, and version histories blur. The intranet becomes a time capsule of yesterday’s priorities.

The hidden cost of broken systems

A messy digital ecosystem isn’t just inconvenient; it’s expensive.

The Asana “Anatomy of Work” Index 2024 found that employees switch between 13+ apps every day, losing an average of 32 working days a year just to digital friction.

When the systems designed to save time steal it instead, trust erodes.

Microsoft’s Work Trend Index shows that 70% of employees feel digitally overwhelmed. And because internal systems don’t meet their needs, 71% of UK workers are now using unapproved consumer AI tools at work (ITPro 2025).

That’s what happens when people innovate out of necessity.

Why this matters now

When people can’t find what they need, don’t trust what they find, and feel drained by the process, everything else suffers: productivity, morale, retention, and wellbeing.

DWG calls this “experience debt.” Every bad interaction accumulates emotional friction. It chips away at trust in leadership, systems, and each other. So it doesn’t become about just making tools easier to use, it’s about restoring some agency. 

How do we get the digital workplace right for the next generation?

From generic to personal

The digital workplace must adapt to role, context, and moment. The best systems feel like they know you, so they’ll surface what’s relevant, and hide what’s not. It’s all about pushing less, and personalising more. Today, it’s all about respecting attention as the rarest resource in the modern workplace.

From content to action

An EXP shouldn’t just inform; it should enable. Approvals, nudges, tasks, learning prompts, all in one flow.

From AI hype to AI with integrity

AI isn’t the star; it’s the scaffolding. It should summarise, recommend, anticipate and never confuse or mislead. Without clean data and clear governance, even the smartest AI just amplifies noise.

From integration chaos to orchestration

The future isn’t “one platform to rule them all.” It’s one entry point that unifies everything else. From your HRIS to your  LMS, collaboration tools and comms; utilising smart APIs and context to pull the most important information without needing to leave the platform. 


What does that mean for the future of the Employee Experience Platform (EXP)? 


Employee experience platforms didn’t fail because they were bad ideas, they often failed because they forgot who they were for. Whether you call it an EXP, intranet or digital workplace, your digital front doors need to be personalised, AI-powered but human-centred. They must be built to anticipate, not dictate, so that they reflect the individual way employees work. And for the first time in years, that finally feels within reach.

More Stories

See all

See Thrive in action

Explore what impact Thrive could make for your team and your learners today.

October 21, 2025
|
6 mins to read

Rethinking the digital workplace: Why EXPs fell short and what’s next 

Why digital workplaces failed to live up to their promise — and how a new, human-centred approach can finally make them work.
Robyn Till
Marketing

For years, the industry has promised a seamless, human-centred “digital workplace.” If we could just build the right intranet or employee experience platform (EXP), we’d unlock connection, productivity, and engagement.

It didn’t happen.

Despite billions spent, most digital workplaces are still unintuitive and underused. They’re built around systems rather than people, and they serve hierarchy rather than experience.

So what really went wrong, and how can we do better? 

The engagement illusion

Research from Gartner shows that nearly 60% of employees struggle to find the information they need to do their job efficiently, even in companies that have invested heavily in digital workplace tech. 

And while intranet usage has technically increased post-pandemic, less than half of workers say those tools make them feel more connected or productive. 

In short, we’ve basically spent millions digitising chaos.

Back in 2019, Employee Experience Platforms were billed as the future of work. But as Bertrand Duperrin points out, the idea “seems to have evaporated.” The tools promised connection, but rarely delivered it.

Instead of reshaping how people work, they layered new tech over legacy systems. They centralised content, but ignored context.

“We digitised chaos and called it transformation.”

Forrester’s 2025 EX Management Platforms report found that only those who combined insight with genuine design thinking made a measurable difference. Most platforms didn’t fail because they were bad products; they failed because they were built for the organisation, not for employees.

So when you drill it down, EXPs just became corporate intranets, acting as a digital filing cabinet with prettier fonts and layouts. But most intranets or “EXPs” collapse under the same pressures: poor search, clunky UX, no (or poor) integrations, and weak governance. 

The result being: 

  • Employers still resorting to email or chat for answers 
  • Policies going out of date faster than they're updated 
  • Single sources of truth splintering into silos 
  • Engagement dashboards looking healthy, while nobody is actually using the system as intended 

The seven pain points every digital workplace suffers from 

According to Digital Workplace Group, most organisations share the same frustrations. These are the symptoms of a broken digital front door:

1. Notification overload

Between Teams, Slack, HR alerts, and inbox pings, employees live in a state of constant interruption. Each context switch fractures attention and focus.

2. Information overload

Gartner found that nearly 60% of employees struggle to find what they need to do their job efficiently (Gartner 2025 HR Trends). The average worker spends nearly two hours a day searching for information that should be seconds away.

3. Onboarding friction

Instead of clarity, new joiners face a mess of systems, links, and logins. The first impression of your company culture is confusion.

4. Cluttered design

Without role-based personalisation, interfaces become junk drawers. No signal, just noise.

5. Workflow disconnect

When the platform doesn’t reflect what employees actually do each day — approvals, priorities, collaboration — it becomes irrelevant.

6. Tech distrust

If content is inconsistent or outdated, employees stop relying on the system entirely. They make their own.

7. Content entropy

Without governance, pages pile up, duplicates appear, and version histories blur. The intranet becomes a time capsule of yesterday’s priorities.

The hidden cost of broken systems

A messy digital ecosystem isn’t just inconvenient; it’s expensive.

The Asana “Anatomy of Work” Index 2024 found that employees switch between 13+ apps every day, losing an average of 32 working days a year just to digital friction.

When the systems designed to save time steal it instead, trust erodes.

Microsoft’s Work Trend Index shows that 70% of employees feel digitally overwhelmed. And because internal systems don’t meet their needs, 71% of UK workers are now using unapproved consumer AI tools at work (ITPro 2025).

That’s what happens when people innovate out of necessity.

Why this matters now

When people can’t find what they need, don’t trust what they find, and feel drained by the process, everything else suffers: productivity, morale, retention, and wellbeing.

DWG calls this “experience debt.” Every bad interaction accumulates emotional friction. It chips away at trust in leadership, systems, and each other. So it doesn’t become about just making tools easier to use, it’s about restoring some agency. 

How do we get the digital workplace right for the next generation?

From generic to personal

The digital workplace must adapt to role, context, and moment. The best systems feel like they know you, so they’ll surface what’s relevant, and hide what’s not. It’s all about pushing less, and personalising more. Today, it’s all about respecting attention as the rarest resource in the modern workplace.

From content to action

An EXP shouldn’t just inform; it should enable. Approvals, nudges, tasks, learning prompts, all in one flow.

From AI hype to AI with integrity

AI isn’t the star; it’s the scaffolding. It should summarise, recommend, anticipate and never confuse or mislead. Without clean data and clear governance, even the smartest AI just amplifies noise.

From integration chaos to orchestration

The future isn’t “one platform to rule them all.” It’s one entry point that unifies everything else. From your HRIS to your  LMS, collaboration tools and comms; utilising smart APIs and context to pull the most important information without needing to leave the platform. 


What does that mean for the future of the Employee Experience Platform (EXP)? 


Employee experience platforms didn’t fail because they were bad ideas, they often failed because they forgot who they were for. Whether you call it an EXP, intranet or digital workplace, your digital front doors need to be personalised, AI-powered but human-centred. They must be built to anticipate, not dictate, so that they reflect the individual way employees work. And for the first time in years, that finally feels within reach.

More Stories

See all

See Thrive in action

Explore what impact Thrive could make for your team and your learners today.